The Acolyte generated significant discussion among Star Wars fans, but not always for the reasons Disney hoped. This short video explores the gap between fan expectations and the final product, examining what elements could have elevated the series from controversial to beloved.

Many viewers felt the show had tremendous potential to explore the darker aspects of the Force and provide fresh perspectives on Jedi philosophy. Instead of capitalizing on these opportunities, the series seemed to miss key elements that could have satisfied both longtime fans and newcomers to the Star Wars universe.